The Taliban announced today that it would cancel reconciliation talks and close its office in Qatar as a result of widespread anger over the killing of 16 Afghan civilians at the hands of an American service member.

USIP's Omar Samad on Taliban Cancelling Talks, Karzai's Request on Troops
Photo courtesy of NY Times/Mauricio Lima

USIP's Omar Samad, a senior Afghanistan expert at USIP had this to say.

"On the surface, the Taliban suspension of Qatar-based talks with the US seems to be tactical and meant as a public relations exercise after the recent Quran burning and tragic Panjwai killing ordeals. While not completely shutting the door, it is also meant to extract concessions from the US on accelerating the Guantanamo prisoner release process, and also to reinforce the Taliban's political position in future phases of negotiations. But it could also have the potential to derail the reconciliation track for the foreseeable future."

And on President Karzai's request for American troops to be confined to major bases - and withdraw from smaller combat outposts like the one on which the American servicemember reportedly responsible for the killings lived:  

"President Karza's request for an immediate NATO pullback to bases and faster transition to Afghan forces by 2013 – a year ahead of schedule – could alter the exit strategy at work. While it puts added pressure on NATO to re-evaluate and accelerate the transition process to nascent Afghan forces, it also sends a political message to dissatisfied Afghans, following the recent Panjwai civilian rampage by a US soldier, as well as to the Taliban who just suspended talks with the US, and still insist on not seeking talks with Karza's side, that he can change end-game terms.

The immediate implication of such a request though is of an operational nature. If and when implemented, how would this retrenchment affect command and control, coordination, counter-insurgency, self-defence and the ability of replacing Afghan forces to do the job in a country with a complex and diverse set of on-the-ground conditions and threat levels?.

Related Publications

Where is Afghanistan Three Years into Taliban Rule?

Where is Afghanistan Three Years into Taliban Rule?

Thursday, September 19, 2024

Lacking formal recognition from all member states, the Taliban will not be present at the U.N. General Assembly next week. Their absence speaks volumes about how the international community struggles to constrain a regime that has repeatedly defied U.N. treaties, sanctions and Security Council resolutions. Three years into Taliban rule, the Afghan people are beset by a host of human rights, economic and humanitarian challenges, with women and girls particularly impacted. Meanwhile, the international community still has no clear approach to dealing with the Taliban, with the regime rejecting a U.N. Security Council resolution calling for a special envoy to develop a roadmap for normalizing Afghanistan’s relations with the international community.

Type: Question and Answer

EconomicsGenderGlobal PolicyHuman Rights

What an ICC Case on Mali Means for Prosecuting Taliban Gender Crimes

What an ICC Case on Mali Means for Prosecuting Taliban Gender Crimes

Wednesday, September 18, 2024

Since the Taliban took power in August 2021, the situation for Afghan women and girls has dramatically deteriorated. Yet there has been little international action, as many in the international community lament the lack of legal, and other, avenues to hold the Taliban accountable for these draconian measures. However, a recent case at the International Criminal Court (ICC) may provide a legal roadmap to prosecute the Taliban.

Type: Analysis

GenderHuman RightsJustice, Security & Rule of Law

China’s Global Security Initiative: Tilting the Balance in Central Asia

China’s Global Security Initiative: Tilting the Balance in Central Asia

Wednesday, August 7, 2024

In recent years, Beijing has been reevaluating its conceptual framework for foreign policy, with a focus on enhancing its role in global governance. With the aim of transforming China into the world's leading country, Chinese leader Xi Jinping has put forward a number of new initiatives — including the Global Security Initiative (GSI) — as a way of creating new formats of cooperation between China and the countries of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and Global South.

Type: Analysis

EconomicsGlobal Policy

What’s Next for the U.N.’s Doha Process on Afghanistan?

What’s Next for the U.N.’s Doha Process on Afghanistan?

Tuesday, July 16, 2024

At the end of June, envoys and representatives from more than 25 countries and international organizations gathered in Doha, Qatar, along with representatives from the Taliban under an U.N.-facilitated framework. This meeting was the third of its kind, widely referred to as “Doha 3,” and part of a process to establish a more coordinated and coherent global approach to Afghanistan’s challenges and the Taliban’s rule.

Type: Analysis

Global Policy

View All Publications