USIP’s Lawrence Woocher discusses the International Criminal Court’s arrest warrant for Libyan leader Col. Muammar al-Qaddafi and how this may impact efforts to end the fighting.


June 28, 2011

USIP’s Lawrence Woocher discusses the International Criminal Court’s arrest warrant for Libyan leader Col. Muammar al-Qaddafi and how this may impact efforts to end the fighting.

On what grounds did the International Criminal Court issue an arrest warrant for Libyan leader Col. Muammar al-Qaddafi?

The investigation began after the United Nations Security Council referred the situation in Libya to the prosecutor of the ICC. Last month, the chief prosecutor, Luis Moreno-Ocampo, submitted requests for arrest warrants for Qaddafi, his son, Saif Al-Islam Qaddafi, and Libya’s intelligence chief, Abdullah Al- Senussi. Ocampo argued that these three individuals were criminally responsible for crimes against humanity. The pre-trial chamber concluded that there are “reasonable grounds to believe” the prosecutor’s case, which is the evidentiary standard required to issue arrest warrants.

Back to Top

What evidence does the court have against him?

The arrest warrant for Qaddafi cites “reasonable grounds to believe that…a State policy was designed at the highest level of the Libyan State machinery and aimed at deterring and quelling, by any means, including by the use of lethal force, the demonstrations of civilians against Qaddafi’s regime.”

The prosecutor presented evidence—based on interviews with insiders and eyewitnesses as well as review of documents, photos and videos—that hundreds of civilians were killed, hundreds injured, and hundreds more arrested by the Libyan Security Forces in the latter half of February 2011, amounting to crimes against humanity.

Back to Top

Is this move primarily symbolic? Will it promote peace and justice in Libya?

Qaddafi clearly won’t submit himself to the Court voluntarily, and the ICC itself has no enforcement power, so the execution of the warrants depends on whether he is dislodged from power. Some fear that the public warrant for his arrest, which can only be suspended by Security Council action, will complicate efforts to persuade Qaddafi to step down in a negotiated settlement.

At the same time, the international community has a strong interest in rejecting impunity in Libya and beyond. Even if Ocampo is right in arguing that “implementing the arrest warrants will be the most effective way to protect civilians under attack in Libya and elsewhere,” there may be a short-term tension between peace and justice.

Back to Top

What happens next?

Chances are that little that is observable will follow directly from the issuance of the arrest warrants. The Court’s actions could affect the internal dynamics and decision making within Qaddafi’s regime, possibly tipping some supporters toward defection, but also reducing options for a negotiated resolution. Unless and until the regime falls, it is difficult to see a path from issuance of the arrest warrants to Qaddafi’s prosecution in the Hague.

Back to Top

 

Learn more about USIP’s work on post-conflict justice.


Related Publications

How Commemoration Can Help Unite a Divided Libya

How Commemoration Can Help Unite a Divided Libya

Thursday, August 24, 2023

In the al-Washishi district of Benghazi a burnt-out car stands in memorial to a slain Libyan National Army (LNA) special forces fighter, serving as a city-wide reflection of the country’s 2014-2017 civil war. The car belonged to Salem (Afareet) Al-Naili, whose father was brutally murdered, one of the many victims of terrorist violence in the city. Inspired by the personal loss of his father, Salem threw himself into the fighting in the city’s civil war and was ultimately also assassinated.

Type: Analysis

Reconciliation

Citizen State and Community Relations in Building Local Governance

Citizen State and Community Relations in Building Local Governance

Monday, August 21, 2023

Since the revolution in 2011 and the toppling of the long-standing regime of Muammar Gaddafi, Libya has experienced various degrees of political instability and conflict. A succession of internationally supported “transitions” have failed to bring the Libyan people a functioning state with a clear social contract based on a shared vision for the nation. This paper discusses the present challenges for good local governance as perceived by Libyan citizens and institutional actors. Through this lens, recommendations are offered for immediate, short-, and medium-term initiatives that can support the improvement of citizen relations with the three traditional arms of the state—the legislative, executive, and judicial branches.

Type: Discussion Paper

Democracy & Governance

Libya Can Move Past Its Political Deadlock, But It Will Take Work to Maintain A ‘Deal’

Libya Can Move Past Its Political Deadlock, But It Will Take Work to Maintain A ‘Deal’

Friday, May 19, 2023

Since 2012, multiple failed political transitions have taken their toll on the Libyan people. The continued and increasingly complex internal divisions and external vectors affecting Libya threaten to send it into another spiral of crisis and violence. Local and national leaders working in good faith to stabilize the country have inevitably grown cynical as ruling elites and their international partners fail to deliver local security and good governance.

Type: Analysis

Conflict Analysis & PreventionPeace Processes

Beyond Elections: Libya Needs Unified Institutions and Reconciliation

Beyond Elections: Libya Needs Unified Institutions and Reconciliation

Wednesday, April 26, 2023

Last week, the U.N. Security Council met to discuss its Libya mission and its new plan to end the country’s political impasse through elections. While credible polls will be a critical step in forging a path to peace, they are not a panacea for addressing this byzantine conflict’s deeply rooted drivers and the intense, bitter rivalries and factionalism that have surfaced since 2011. Indeed, previous efforts to hold elections have buckled under the weight of the intricate dynamics at play. Over a decade after the fall of Muammar Qaddafi, resolving Libya's complex conflict will require a multifaceted approach that prioritizes building trust among Libyans.

Type: Analysis

Conflict Analysis & PreventionDemocracy & Governance

View All Publications