The Fragility Study Group is an independent, non-partisan, effort of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, the Center for a New American Security and the United States Institute of Peace. The chair report of the study group, U.S. Leadership and the Challenge of State Fragility, was released on September 12. This brief is part of a series authored by scholars from the three institutions that build on the chair report to discuss the implications of fragility on existing U.S. tools, strategic interests and challenges. 

Introduction

Resilience is the ability of a state and society to absorb, adapt, and transform in response to a shock or long-term stressor. A central feature of resilience is a strong social compact between the state and society on their respective and mutual roles and responsibilities. There are several constituent parts of a social compact. On the side of the state, it is the capacity to manage societal expectations, the ability to ensure basic provisions, and the management of state resources in ways that meet societal needs.2 Transactions between society and the state – the essence of the compact – take place through formal and informal institutional mechanisms that instill mutual trust and benefit, if executed equitably and fairly, and ensure a reservoir of confidence and source of stability during crises. The compact can also shape the norms and set the conditions for societal relations; government inclusivity inspires horizontal cohesion across society, helping to establish trusted frameworks and forums for group collaboration. Thus, a social compact is not only an agreement or a relationship, but a complex set of interactions and associations that act as an immune system, or resilience, to internal and external stress and shock.3

Experience shows that shocks and stressors have different impacts across geographies and groups. Certain states and societies are better able to with-stand them, while others tip into spirals of fragility and violence. Part of this is due to the targeted nature of the threat; for example, violent extremism often spreads through localized conflicts, with extremist groups manipulating local grievances to gain position and traction. The other part, however, is about resilience capacities. Social cohesion is a factor in determining how states and societies respond to shocks. Studies have shown that communities in Kenya, India, and Iraq that were able to resist violence, while their neighbors succumbed, had high levels of working trust built up through community associations (businesses, clubs, neighborhoods) that encouraged ethnic and religious groups to work together for the benefit of the collective whole.4 These associative relationships stopped retributive cycles of violence and provided avenues for crisis communication and negotiation. Adaptive leadership – characterized by leaders who clearly assess risk, engage constituents inclusively, and organize collectively in response to shocks – is also key, as are citizens who believe in their own collective efficacy, that is, their ability to act and change outcomes.5 Resilience, in many ways, is about tapping into these existing capacities to address the forces of fragility and doing this through innovation, adaptation, and learning.

Lauren Van Metre is a resiliency expert.


Related Publications

Sahel Coup Regime’s Split from ECOWAS Risks Instability in Coastal West Africa

Sahel Coup Regime’s Split from ECOWAS Risks Instability in Coastal West Africa

Thursday, October 24, 2024

As policymakers monitor the spread of terrorist violence and warfare from the Sahel region, one broad threat to international and U.S. interests is West Africa’s 3.4 million people uprooted by the Sahel’s chaos. So far, over 110,000 have fled to four West African coastal states, a migration that signals new dangers to the region’s democracies, and to the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), the multinational body that for decades has been central to promoting region-wide stability.

Type: Analysis

Democracy & GovernanceFragility & Resilience

Quatre moyens par lesquels les États-Unis peuvent aider à faire progresser Haïti

Quatre moyens par lesquels les États-Unis peuvent aider à faire progresser Haïti

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Depuis que Haïti a conclu un accord politique début avril pour avancer vers une « transition ordonnée », de nombreux progrès ont été réalisés. Médié par la Communauté des Caraïbes (CARICOM), cet accord fixe à février 2026 l’échéance pour la mise en place d’un gouvernement et d’un parlement élus. Bien que politiquement et administrativement fragile, une structure de gouvernance transitoire est en place, dirigée par un Conseil présidentiel de transition (CPT) et le Premier ministre Garry Conille. Une mission multinationale de soutien à la sécurité (MSS), dirigée par le Kenya, est désormais active dans le pays et travaille à stabiliser la situation sécuritaire.

Type: Analysis

Fragility & Resilience

Four Ways the U.S. Can Help Advance Haiti’s Progress

Four Ways the U.S. Can Help Advance Haiti’s Progress

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Since Haiti reached a political agreement in early April to push ahead with an “orderly transition," much progress has been made. Mediated by the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), that deal has a February 2026 timetable for an elected government and parliament. Although politically and administratively wobbly, a transitional governance structure is in place, led by a Transition Presidential Council (TPC) and Prime Minister Garry Conille. A Kenyan-led Multinational Security Support mission (MSS) is now active in the country and working to stabilize the security situation. Working with Haiti’s political and civil society leadership, the country’s diaspora and key international actors, the U.S. can help build on these milestones and pave a sustainable path out of Haiti’s long-running crises.

Type: Analysis

Fragility & Resilience

Explainer: What Caused the Recent Unrest in New Caledonia?

Explainer: What Caused the Recent Unrest in New Caledonia?

Thursday, May 23, 2024

Violence engulfed New Caledonia last week as the French National Assembly passed a constitutional amendment that will undermine the political representation of the Pacific territory’s Indigenous Kanak people. During days of unrest unprecedented since the 1980s, security forces and protesters clashed across the archipelago, leaving six dead and hundreds injured. Buildings and vehicles were set on fire in the capital, Nouméa, while streets were barricaded throughout the territory, flights were grounded and New Caledonia was placed under a state of emergency.

Type: Question and Answer

Democracy & GovernanceFragility & Resilience

View All Publications