Three weeks after the August 20th national elections, the outcome of the election remains contested. Results posted by Afghanistan’s Independent Election Commission show President Hamid Karzai at 54% and his main challenger Dr. Abdullah at 28% with 91.6% of polling stations tallied. But widespread allegations of fraud have marred the results,  with over 2000 complaints filed to the Afghan Elections Complaints Commission (ECC). Please join us for a discussion of these issues with experts just arrived from Afghanistan, all of whom have observed the Afghan political process up close for the last few years.
 

Three weeks after the August 20th national elections, the outcome of the election remains contested. Results posted by Afghanistan’s Independent Election Commission show President Hamid Karzai at 54% and his main challenger Dr. Abdullah at 28% with 91.6% of polling stations tallied. But widespread allegations of fraud have marred the result, with over 2000 complaints filed to the Afghan Elections Complaints Commission (ECC), which called for a partial nation-wide recount on September 8 after finding “clear and convincing evidence of fraud” in several provinces.

There are numerous other larger concerns arising from these elections as well. Was turnout – perhaps as low as 30-35% -- sufficient for an electoral mandate? Why did so few people vote – insurgent threats, warlord intimidation, apathy? Were women able to express their voices in this election – as candidates, voters, or in the media? Are elections merely an ethnic census in Afghanistan? What impact will the allegations of fraud have on the overall perception of a government already accused of corruption? Will this process reinforce a culture of impunity? What was the outcome of the Provincial Council elections?

Please join us for a discussion of these issues with experts just arrived from Afghanistan, all of whom have observed the Afghan political process up close for the last few years. John Dempsey, USIP’s Senior Rule of Law Advisor in Kabul, has been working on the rule of law in Afghanistan for the last six years. Palwasha Hassan, an Afghan woman and head of Rights and Democracy in Kabul, is a prominent advocate on human rights and gender issues. Noah Coburn, USIP’s Traditional Justice Specialist in Kabul, is an anthropologist who conducted fieldwork on local political dynamics and coauthor of, “Patronage, Posturing, Duty, Demographics: Why Afghans Voted in 2009” (AREU, 2009).

Speakers

  • John Dempsey
    Senior Rule of Law Advisor, U.S. Institute of Peace Kabul
  • Palwasha Hassan
    Jennings Randolf Afghanistan Fellow, USIP and Afghanistan Country Director, Rights and Democracy
  • Noah Coburn
    Traditional Justice Specialist, U.S. Institute of Peace Kabul
  • J Alexander Thier, Moderator
    Director, Afghanistan and Pakistan, U.S. Institute of Peace

Related Publications

What’s Next for the U.N.’s Doha Process on Afghanistan?

What’s Next for the U.N.’s Doha Process on Afghanistan?

Tuesday, July 16, 2024

At the end of June, envoys and representatives from more than 25 countries and international organizations gathered in Doha, Qatar, along with representatives from the Taliban under an U.N.-facilitated framework. This meeting was the third of its kind, widely referred to as “Doha 3,” and part of a process to establish a more coordinated and coherent global approach to Afghanistan’s challenges and the Taliban’s rule.

Type: Analysis

Global Policy

How to Support Female Entrepreneurs in Afghanistan

How to Support Female Entrepreneurs in Afghanistan

Tuesday, June 25, 2024

Potential areas of cooperation between the Taliban and the international community, such as private sector development and alternative livelihoods to now-banned opium poppy cultivation, will be on the agenda at a meeting of international envoys for Afghanistan hosted by the United Nations in Doha from June 30 to July 1. Discussions on women’s rights are not included, as the Taliban consider it an internal matter. This is ironic, given that the private sector is one area where the Taliban allow limited women’s participation.

Type: Analysis

EconomicsGender

As Taliban Poppy Ban Continues, Afghan Poverty Deepens

As Taliban Poppy Ban Continues, Afghan Poverty Deepens

Thursday, June 20, 2024

Afghanistan, historically the leading source of the world’s illegal opium, is on-track for an unprecedented second year of dramatically reduced poppy cultivation, reflecting the Taliban regime’s continuing prohibition against growing the raw material for opiates. The crackdown has won plaudits in international circles, but its full implications call for clear-eyed analysis and well considered responses by the U.S. and others. The ban has deepened the poverty of millions of rural Afghans who depended on the crop for their livelihoods, yet done nothing to diminish opiate exports, as wealthier landowners sell off inventories. The unfortunate reality is that any aid mobilized to offset harm from the ban will be grossly insufficient and ultimately wasted unless it fosters broad-based rural and agricultural development that benefits the most affected poorer households. 

Type: Analysis

Economics

View All Publications